The Kid from Spain - 1932
back| Released by | United Artists |
| Director | Leo McCarey |
| Producer | Samuel Goldwyn |
| Script | Written by William Anthony McGuire, based on a story by Mack Gordon and Harry Ruby |
| Cinematography | Gregg Toland |
| Music by | Alfred Newman |
| Running time | 96 minutes |
| Film budget | $1 million |
| Box office sales | $2,6 million |
| Main cast | Eddie Cantor - Lyda Roberti - Robert Young - Ruth Hall |
The Kid from Spain
A Lively Musical Comedy of Mistaken Identity against the Backdrop of a Bullfighting Spectacle
he Kid from Spain (1932) is a pre-Code musical comedy directed by Leo McCarey, starring Eddie Cantor as Eddie Williams, a college student who becomes entangled in a case of mistaken identity as a famed Spanish bullfighter. The film follows Eddie’s comedic misadventures, romantic entanglements, and daring antics, culminating in a chaotic and hilarious bullfighting finale. Highlighted by Cantor’s quick wit, physical comedy, and energetic musical performances, the film also features lavish Busby Berkeley-choreographed dance sequences that add visual spectacle.
The movie was a box office success, solidifying Eddie Cantor’s status as a leading comedic star of the 1930s. Its bold humor, risqué pre-Code elements, and extravagant musical numbers reflect the creative freedom of its era. While culturally dated in some aspects, The Kid from Spain remains a vibrant example of early Hollywood musical comedy, blending humor, romance, and spectacle with lasting influence.
The Kid from Spain – 1932
Summary
The Kid from Spain is a musical comedy that combines lighthearted humor, romance, and elements of mistaken identity. Eddie Cantor stars as Eddie Williams, a hapless but well-meaning college student who finds himself entangled in a series of comedic misadventures. The story begins with Eddie being expelled from college after being mistakenly accused of aiding his friend Ricardo (played by Robert Young) in sneaking a group of women into their dormitory.
Fleeing the scandal, Eddie and Ricardo head to Mexico, where Ricardo’s aristocratic family resides. Once there, Eddie discovers that Ricardo’s family is deeply involved in the world of bullfighting, a sport foreign and intimidating to Eddie. Adding to the confusion, Eddie inadvertently finds himself caught in a web of mistaken identity when he is confused with a famous Spanish bullfighter. This case of mistaken identity thrusts Eddie into the spotlight, leading to a series of comedic situations as he tries to maintain the ruse.
Romance blossoms as Ricardo falls for Anita Gomez (Ruth Hall), and Eddie develops a charming connection with Rosalie (Lyda Roberti), a vivacious dancer. However, their romantic endeavors are complicated by Alonzo Gomez (John Miljan), a villainous character who aims to exploit the situation for his own gain. Alonzo threatens to expose Eddie’s deception, escalating the tension and driving the plot forward.
The climax of the film is set in a bullring, where Eddie, still impersonating a bullfighter, must face an actual bull. The scene blends slapstick humor with genuine suspense, showcasing Eddie Cantor’s physical comedy skills and charisma. The resolution ties together the romantic and comedic elements, with Eddie’s true identity revealed, the villains thwarted, and the protagonists achieving their romantic and personal goals.
Analysis
The Kid from Spain is a quintessential example of the pre-Code era of Hollywood filmmaking. It is bold, playful, and uninhibited, showcasing elements that would later become taboo under the stricter Production Code enforcement. The film is notable for its blend of musical numbers, comedy, and romance, all executed with the lavish production values characteristic of Samuel Goldwyn’s projects.
Performance and Characterization
Eddie Cantor’s performance is the heart of the film. His energetic presence, rapid-fire delivery, and ability to seamlessly transition between humor and vulnerability make Eddie Williams a memorable and endearing protagonist. Cantor’s unique blend of physical comedy and verbal wit shines in the bullfighting scenes, where his exaggerated fear and awkward attempts to mimic a matador are both hilarious and relatable.
Lyda Roberti, as Rosalie, adds a layer of charm and sophistication to the film. Her musical performances are engaging, and her chemistry with Cantor provides many of the film’s standout moments. Robert Young and Ruth Hall, as the romantic leads, bring sincerity and balance to the comedic chaos.
Themes
The film explores themes of identity, social class, and the pursuit of love. Eddie’s journey from a bumbling outsider to an unlikely hero mirrors a classic "fish out of water" narrative, emphasizing the value of self-reliance and adaptability. The romance between Ricardo and Anita contrasts the comedic turmoil, grounding the story with a sincere emotional core.
Direction and Production
Leo McCarey’s direction brings a dynamic rhythm to the film, balancing slapstick comedy with musical interludes and moments of genuine tension. The use of elaborate set pieces, particularly in the bullfighting scenes, highlights the production's opulence. Gregg Toland’s cinematography captures both the grandeur of the Mexican setting and the intimacy of the character interactions, enhancing the film's visual appeal.
Alfred Newman’s musical score adds a vibrant energy to the film, with the songs serving as both narrative devices and showcases for the performers’ talents. The choreography and staging of the musical numbers reflect the influence of Busby Berkeley, creating a sense of spectacle and extravagance.
Cultural Context
As a pre-Code film, The Kid from Spain contains elements of risqué humor and suggestive dialogue that push the boundaries of its time. The portrayal of Mexican culture, however, is filtered through the lens of 1930s Hollywood and includes stereotypes that may feel dated or problematic by modern standards.
Legacy
The Kid from Spain is remembered for its engaging performances, witty humor, and lavish production. It solidified Eddie Cantor’s reputation as a comedic star and showcased the collaborative talents of McCarey, Goldwyn, and Newman. While some elements may feel antiquated today, the film remains a valuable artifact of early 20th-century cinema, illustrating the creative freedoms and exuberance of the pre-Code era.
In summary, The Kid from Spain is an entertaining blend of comedy, music, and romance that stands as a testament to the vibrant creativity of 1930s Hollywood. Its humor, energy, and charm continue to resonate with audiences, making it a classic worth revisiting.
The Bullfight Scene from The Kid from Spain
Full Cast
• Eddie Cantor as Eddie Williams
• Lyda Roberti as Rosalie
• Robert Young as Ricardo
• Ruth Hall as Anita Gomez
• John Miljan as Alonzo Gomez
• Noah Beery as Sheriff
• Stanley Fields as a Bandit
• Robert Emmett O'Connor as Detective Crawford
• J. Carrol Naish as Pedro
• Harry Watson as Bullfighter
• Paul Porcasi as Señor Alvarez
• Earle Foxe as Duke Henri
• Hugh Herbert as a Tourist (uncredited cameo)
Analysis of Leo McCarey’s Direction in The Kid from Spain
Leo McCarey’s direction of The Kid from Spain reveals his deft ability to balance humor, romance, and spectacle, creating a film that is both entertaining and technically impressive. Though primarily known for his later dramatic comedies (The Awful Truth, Make Way for Tomorrow, and Going My Way), The Kid from Spain showcases McCarey’s talent for crafting engaging narratives through comedic timing and a strong focus on character interactions.
Seamless Integration of Genres
McCarey masterfully blends multiple genres in The Kid from Spain. The film incorporates musical numbers, slapstick comedy, and romantic subplots, all tied together with a cohesive narrative flow. His ability to shift between these elements without losing the audience’s attention demonstrates a sharp understanding of pacing. For instance, the high-energy comedy of Eddie Cantor’s antics contrasts beautifully with the romantic tension between Ricardo and Anita, creating a rhythm that keeps the story dynamic.
Character-Centric Approach
One of McCarey’s strengths as a director is his focus on character-driven storytelling. In The Kid from Spain, this is evident in his treatment of Eddie Williams, the protagonist. McCarey ensures that Eddie’s comedic mishaps never reduce him to a mere caricature. Instead, Eddie is portrayed as an endearing underdog whose charm and resourcefulness ultimately make him a hero. McCarey’s direction allows Eddie Cantor’s natural charisma to shine, making the character relatable and sympathetic despite his bumbling nature.
The supporting cast also benefits from McCarey’s attention to character. Rosalie, played by Lyda Roberti, is more than just a romantic interest; her vivacity and wit make her a compelling counterpart to Eddie. McCarey gives each character their moments to shine, ensuring they feel integral to the story rather than peripheral.
Visual Storytelling and Cinematic Flair
McCarey demonstrates a keen eye for visual storytelling, using the camera to enhance both the humor and the drama. While The Kid from Spain is not as visually experimental as some of his later works, it still contains moments of inventive staging. For example, the bullfighting scenes are choreographed with an almost theatrical precision, blending suspense and comedy in a way that highlights Eddie’s vulnerability while amplifying the absurdity of the situation.
The musical numbers, choreographed by Busby Berkeley, are another testament to McCarey’s collaborative approach to direction. While Berkeley’s extravagant style dominates these sequences, McCarey ensures they feel integrated into the narrative rather than standalone spectacles. The interplay between McCarey’s narrative focus and Berkeley’s visual extravagance creates a unique blend of story and spectacle.
Mastery of Comedy
McCarey’s background in comedy, honed during his time working with legendary acts like Laurel and Hardy, is evident throughout the film. His timing is impeccable, ensuring that jokes land effectively without overstaying their welcome. He also has a knack for physical comedy, as seen in Eddie’s bullfighting scenes, which are a masterclass in using physicality to elicit laughter.
Moreover, McCarey understands the importance of contrast in comedy. He uses moments of stillness or sincerity to make the comedic beats stand out even more. For example, scenes of quiet romance between Ricardo and Anita serve as a counterpoint to Eddie’s over-the-top antics, making the humor feel fresh and impactful.
Cultural and Contextual Sensitivity
While The Kid from Spain is a product of its time, and some of its portrayals of Mexican culture may feel stereotypical to modern audiences, McCarey’s direction reflects a genuine effort to use the setting as a vibrant backdrop for the story. The Mexican bullring and the colorful costumes add authenticity and visual richness to the film. However, it is worth noting that these elements are filtered through the lens of 1930s Hollywood, with cultural nuances often simplified for comedic effect.
Collaborative Spirit
McCarey’s collaborative nature is evident in his work with the film’s cast and crew. He allows Eddie Cantor the freedom to bring his vaudeville-inspired humor to the role, while also working closely with choreographer Busby Berkeley to ensure the musical numbers complement the story. His collaboration with cinematographer Gregg Toland results in a film that is visually polished and engaging, with lighting and composition that elevate the narrative.
Legacy of McCarey’s Direction
The Kid from Spain is not as critically lauded as some of McCarey’s later works, but it remains an important piece in his filmography. It highlights his ability to juggle complex narratives, develop richly comedic characters, and create films that resonate with audiences. The film also serves as a precursor to his more sophisticated comedies, showcasing the early seeds of his talent for blending humor with heartfelt emotion.
Conclusion
Leo McCarey’s direction in The Kid from Spain is a testament to his versatility and skill as a filmmaker. He crafts a film that is equal parts funny, romantic, and visually engaging, with a sharp focus on character and comedic timing. While some aspects of the film reflect the cultural attitudes of its era, McCarey’s direction elevates it into a lively and memorable cinematic experience. The film stands as an example of his ability to entertain while setting the stage for his later, more acclaimed works.
Eddie Cantor’s Performance in The Kid from Spain
Eddie Cantor’s performance in The Kid from Spain is a masterclass in comedic timing, physicality, and charm, showcasing his unique ability to carry a film with his dynamic screen presence. As the central character, Eddie Williams, Cantor anchors the movie with a portrayal that blends slapstick humor, quick wit, and a touch of vulnerability, making him an engaging and memorable protagonist.
________________________________________
Cantor’s Physical Comedy
Eddie Cantor was renowned for his vaudeville roots, and this background shines in his performance. In The Kid from Spain, his physicality is at the heart of many comedic moments. Whether he’s fumbling through his impersonation of a bullfighter, attempting to navigate awkward social situations, or reacting with exaggerated expressions of fear and confusion, Cantor’s physical comedy is consistently precise and effective.
• The Bullfighting Scene: One of the film’s standout moments, Cantor’s antics in the bullring epitomize his comedic talent. His over-the-top gestures, clumsy attempts at bravery, and panicked reactions create a hilariously tense sequence that plays to his strengths as a performer. He uses his body not only for humor but also to elicit sympathy, as the audience roots for him to survive the absurd predicament.
________________________________________
Verbal Wit and Delivery
Cantor’s rapid-fire dialogue delivery is another highlight of his performance. His lines are filled with sharp humor, often laced with double entendres and clever wordplay that push the boundaries of pre-Code comedy. His comedic rhythm feels natural, a reflection of his extensive experience on stage and radio, where timing was everything.
• Playful Banter: Cantor’s interactions with Rosalie (Lyda Roberti) and other characters are filled with lively repartee. His ability to shift between self-deprecating humor and flirtatious charm makes these exchanges engaging and endearing.
________________________________________
Balancing Humor with Vulnerability
What sets Cantor apart is his ability to infuse his character with genuine vulnerability. While Eddie Williams is primarily a comedic figure, he is also an underdog who faces numerous challenges. Cantor ensures that the audience not only laughs at Eddie’s mishaps but also roots for his success. This emotional resonance adds depth to what could have been a purely comedic role.
• Relatable Hero: Eddie’s naivety and determination make him a relatable figure. Cantor portrays him as a well-meaning, if occasionally hapless, individual who stumbles through life with optimism and resourcefulness. This makes his eventual triumphs feel earned and satisfying.
________________________________________
Musical Performance
As a skilled singer and performer, Eddie Cantor’s musical numbers are another key element of his performance. His songs in The Kid from Spain are lively, humorous, and seamlessly integrated into the narrative. Cantor’s expressive face and body language add a visual element to his singing, elevating the comedic and emotional impact of these moments.
• Signature Style: Cantor’s musical performances are marked by his trademark energy and charm. He engages the audience directly, often breaking the fourth wall or using exaggerated gestures to draw viewers into the humor of the songs.
________________________________________
Engaging the Audience
Cantor’s charisma is palpable throughout the film. He often breaks the fourth wall, a technique that draws the audience into the story and reinforces his connection with them. His asides, winks, and direct glances to the camera create a sense of intimacy, making the viewer feel like a participant in the comedy rather than a passive observer.
________________________________________
Cultural Context and Sensitivity
While Cantor’s performance is undeniably entertaining, it’s important to note that some aspects of his humor and portrayal reflect the cultural attitudes of the 1930s. His use of exaggerated facial expressions, such as his famous wide-eyed look, was emblematic of his style but has since been critiqued for occasionally leaning into caricature. In The Kid from Spain, his performance occasionally skirts cultural stereotypes, particularly in scenes where he impersonates a Spanish bullfighter. While these moments are played for laughs, they also highlight the era’s limited sensitivity to cultural representation.
________________________________________
Legacy of His Performance
Eddie Cantor’s work in The Kid from Spain solidified his status as one of the preeminent comedic stars of the 1930s. His ability to captivate audiences with his humor, musical talent, and relatable charm made the film a box office success. Cantor’s performance remains a defining example of early Hollywood comedy, showcasing the transition from vaudeville to the silver screen.
Conclusion
Eddie Cantor’s performance in The Kid from Spain is a vibrant blend of humor, music, and heart. His physical comedy, quick wit, and ability to connect with audiences make him the driving force behind the film’s success. While certain aspects of the performance reflect the sensibilities of its time, Cantor’s energy and talent continue to resonate, securing his place as a pioneer of screen comedy.
Notable Quotes from The Kid from Spain
Eddie Williams (Eddie Cantor):
• "Me? A bullfighter? The only bull I've ever fought was on a menu!"
(Eddie reacts to being mistaken for a matador, highlighting his comedic bewilderment.)
• "If I don't survive this, tell my tailor I'm sorry about the suit!"
(A classic Eddie quip before entering the bullring, blending humor and nervousness.)
• "I may not be Spanish, but I sure know how to dance around trouble!"
(Eddie’s lighthearted attempt to make the best of his situation.)
________________________________________
Rosalie (Lyda Roberti):
• "You don't need to fight bulls to be brave, Eddie. Sometimes all it takes is showing up."
(Rosalie offers a moment of sincerity amidst the comedy, encouraging Eddie.)
• "With a face like yours, you should charge admission for the expressions!"
(Rosalie teasing Eddie in their playful banter, emphasizing their chemistry.)
________________________________________
Ricardo (Robert Young):
• "Eddie, you’ve been my friend through thick and thin. Mostly thin, though!"
(Ricardo jokes about their misadventures, showcasing their camaraderie.)
• "In Mexico, we don’t run from bulls. We face them. But in your case, maybe running isn’t such a bad idea."
(Ricardo’s humorous acknowledgment of Eddie’s lack of bravery.)
________________________________________
Alonzo Gomez (John Miljan):
• "A bullring is no place for a clown... unless the clown wants to be trampled."
(Alonzo, the antagonist, taunts Eddie, adding tension to the story.)
________________________________________
General Humor and Witty Exchanges:
• Eddie: "Why does everyone keep calling me 'El Matador'? I’m more of an 'El Cowardor.'"
(Eddie continues to poke fun at his predicament.)
• Rosalie: "Don’t worry, Eddie. You’ll be fine."
Eddie: "Fine? I’m two steps away from being a piñata for a bull!"
(A humorous exchange reflecting Eddie’s comedic outlook on danger.)
________________________________________
Musical Numbers (Paraphrased Lyric Highlights):
• "I may not be a hero, but I can make you smile, and sometimes that’s all we need for a little while."
(From one of Eddie’s musical numbers, showcasing his optimistic, lighthearted spirit.)
Classic Scenes
The Bullfighting Finale
The climax of the film is undoubtedly its most iconic scene. Eddie Williams (Eddie Cantor), mistaken for a renowned matador, is thrust into a real bullring. This sequence combines slapstick comedy with genuine suspense. Eddie’s exaggerated attempts to face the bull—using an umbrella as a cape or nervously hiding behind barriers—showcase Cantor’s physical comedy skills. The crowd’s enthusiastic cheers and Eddie’s panicked expressions create a blend of humor and tension that makes this scene unforgettable.
Why It’s Classic:
• It encapsulates Eddie Cantor’s comedic style: a mix of wit, physicality, and relatable vulnerability.
• The bullring setting, with its elaborate choreography and grand scale, provides a visually striking backdrop.
________________________________________
The Musical Introduction to Eddie
Early in the film, Eddie sings a comedic and self-deprecating song that introduces his character. Surrounded by college students, Eddie’s performance is full of witty lyrics and animated gestures, setting the tone for his role as the underdog hero. This number also highlights Cantor’s ability to engage the audience directly, making them feel like participants in his misadventures.
Why It’s Classic:
• It establishes Eddie’s charm and humor right from the start.
• The song reflects the pre-Code era’s playful, risqué humor.
________________________________________
The Robbery Scene
Eddie and Ricardo (Robert Young) encounter a group of bandits while traveling to Mexico. Eddie’s nervous attempts to negotiate with the outlaws lead to a series of comedic misunderstandings. His quick thinking and knack for improvisation turn the situation into an absurdly funny escape.
Why It’s Classic:
• This scene highlights Eddie’s resourcefulness and comedic timing.
• The interactions with the bandits provide a humorous contrast to the more sophisticated comedic elements in other parts of the film.
________________________________________
The Busby Berkeley Choreographed Dance Sequence
Busby Berkeley’s extravagant choreography is on full display in one of the film’s grand musical numbers. Featuring intricate patterns formed by dancers in vibrant costumes, the sequence is a feast for the eyes. Eddie Cantor’s energetic participation in the number adds a layer of humor and excitement.
Why It’s Classic:
• Berkeley’s elaborate, kaleidoscopic choreography remains a hallmark of 1930s musical cinema.
• The juxtaposition of Eddie’s comedic antics with the visual elegance of the dancers creates a unique and memorable spectacle.
________________________________________
Eddie’s Disguises
Throughout the film, Eddie dons various disguises to avoid trouble. One of the funniest instances is when he pretends to be a Spanish matador, complete with an exaggerated accent and over-the-top gestures. His efforts to mimic the poise and confidence of a real bullfighter are hilariously awkward, leading to comical misunderstandings.
Why It’s Classic:
• The disguises allow Eddie Cantor to showcase his versatility as a performer.
• The humor in these scenes is timeless, relying on universal themes of deception and mistaken identity.
________________________________________
The Romantic Balcony Scene
In a quieter moment, Ricardo serenades Anita Gomez (Ruth Hall) from her balcony, while Eddie provides unintentional comic relief. His interruptions, attempts to mimic Ricardo, and eventual mishaps undercut the romance with humor, creating a perfect balance of sentiment and comedy.
Why It’s Classic:
• This scene contrasts Eddie’s comedic antics with Ricardo’s genuine romantic overtures.
• It exemplifies the film’s ability to seamlessly blend humor and romance.
________________________________________
The Prison Escape Scene
Eddie finds himself locked up after a series of misunderstandings. His escape plan, which involves a mix of wit and sheer luck, is both suspenseful and hilarious. This scene highlights Eddie’s ingenuity and his knack for turning dire situations into comedic gold.
Why It’s Classic:
• It’s a prime example of Eddie’s “lovable underdog” persona.
• The escalating absurdity of the escape keeps the audience laughing while rooting for Eddie.
No Awards for the Movie
he Kid from Spain (1932) did not receive any major awards or nominations during its release. However, it was a commercial success and showcased the talents of Eddie Cantor, director Leo McCarey, and choreographer Busby Berkeley. The film is notable for featuring the film debut of Jane Wyman.
Despite its lack of formal accolades, the film remains a significant example of early 1930s musical comedy.